Clear ESG logoClear ESG
The rulesExamplesChecklistGuidesSourcesESG basicsFree guideContactGet Started
  1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. How to write environmental claims that hold up

Clear ESG guide

How to write environmental claims that hold up

Aug 12, 2026 / 9 min read / Clear ESG

A practical guide for marketers, product teams, and anyone who has to approve a green claim.

An environmental claim can start as a good idea and still create a bad impression. A product team knows that one component uses recycled material. The campaign turns that fact into “better for the planet.” The copy sounds positive, but the evidence only supports a small part of the story.

That gap is where greenwashing risk begins. It does not depend on a team setting out to deceive anyone. The important question is what a reasonable customer is likely to understand from the whole communication, and whether the business can support that understanding with reliable evidence.

This guide gives you a repeatable way to write and review claims. It complements the greenwashing examples and the green claims checklist on Clear ESG.

Start with the fact, not the adjective

Words such as “green,” “clean,” “conscious,” “responsible,” and “sustainable” feel familiar because they are common in marketing. Their familiarity is also the problem. They can suggest a broad environmental benefit without telling a customer what actually changed.

The safer starting point is a fact that has a defined boundary. What part of the product changed? What did you measure? Against what baseline? Over what period? A factual starting point does not guarantee that a claim is compliant, but it gives the review something concrete to test.

Compare two beginnings:

  • “A cleaner choice.” This suggests a general benefit and leaves the customer to fill in the details.
  • “The outer carton is made with 80% recycled paper by weight.” This identifies the part, the material, and the percentage.

The second sentence still needs evidence. It may also need qualification if the recycled content varies by market or batch. But it gives a customer a much narrower and more honest impression.

The UK Green Claims Code uses the same practical direction: claims should be truthful, clear, and not omit information that changes their meaning. For EU-facing work, the Dutch ACM sustainability claims guidance adds a practical five-part test: be clear and specific, use current facts, make fair comparisons, describe ambitions concretely, and make labels useful rather than confusing.

Define the scope before you write the headline

Many claims fail because their scope is unclear. A claim about packaging is read as a claim about the whole product. A claim about one factory is read as a claim about the whole company. A claim about a future target is read as a statement about current performance.

Write the scope in plain language before you shorten the claim for a headline. You can ask four questions:

  1. Is this claim about the product, its packaging, the manufacturing process, the company, or a specific project?
  2. Does it apply to every item, a product range, a market, or only selected batches?
  3. Is it about current performance, a historical result, or a future ambition?
  4. Would the claim still be true if a customer read only the headline and saw the image?

This last question matters because customers rarely read marketing in the order that a compliance team reviews it. They may see the image, headline, badge, and price first. A qualification buried below the fold may not correct a broad first impression.

The European Union directive on empowering consumers for the green transition is a useful reminder that environmental labels and claims are judged in the context in which they appear. A narrow fact should not be dressed up as a general guarantee.

Treat evidence as part of the writing process

Evidence should not arrive after the copy is finished. If a claim is written first and evidence is found later, the evidence often gets bent to fit the words. Reverse that order. Start a claim file with the source evidence, then draft language that stays within its boundaries.

A useful claim file includes:

  • The final wording, including the headline, label, image text, packaging text, and any spoken script.
  • The scope, including product, market, supplier, factory, and time period.
  • The method, including units, assumptions, system boundaries, and any exclusions.
  • The source evidence, including reports, test results, certification records, or supplier documents.
  • The review record, including who approved the claim and when it must be checked again.

The file is not bureaucracy for its own sake. It creates a clean line between a fact, an interpretation, and a marketing phrase. If someone asks “where did this number come from?” the answer should not depend on finding an old message in a campaign chat.

If your source is a supplier statement, record what the supplier actually verified. If it is a life-cycle assessment, record the functional unit and system boundary. If it is a certification, record the scheme, certificate, scope, and expiry date. Evidence can be strong for one claim and irrelevant for another.

Be careful with percentages and comparisons

Percentages look precise, but precision can create a false sense of certainty. “30% less water” is not meaningful without a baseline and a unit. Less than which product? Measured where? Per item, per kilogram, per use, or across the whole operation?

A defensible comparison usually names three things:

  1. The item or period used as the baseline.
  2. The unit or functional basis used for the comparison.
  3. The method and date of the measurement.

For example, “uses 30% less water than our 2024 bottle, measured per bottle in factory testing” is still a claim that needs proof, but it is more informative than “uses 30% less water.” The customer can understand what is being compared. The figures in these examples are illustrative patterns, not substantiated claims for a particular business.

The CMA guidance on making environmental claims explains why comparisons need to be fair and meaningful. A business should not select a weak baseline simply because it creates a better marketing number.

Do not hide the trade-off

Environmental performance is rarely one-dimensional. A material may reduce one impact and increase another. A product may be recyclable in theory but not accepted by local collection systems. A lower-carbon delivery option may take longer or require a different service level.

You do not need to turn every advertisement into a technical report. You do need to avoid creating a misleading overall impression. If a limitation changes how a normal customer would evaluate the claim, it belongs close to the claim, in language people can understand.

That is why “made with natural materials” can be risky. Natural does not automatically mean lower impact, safer, renewable, biodegradable, or responsibly sourced. If the meaningful fact is that the outer fabric is organic cotton, say that. If the product also has a synthetic lining, do not use the outer fabric to imply that the whole product has the same property.

The ASA and CAP environmental claims guidance includes useful examples of how the overall impression of an advertisement can matter. Images, colors, symbols, and qualifications all contribute to what the audience takes away.

Separate a target from a current result

Future-facing language deserves its own review. “We will be net zero by 2040” is not the same type of statement as “our emissions fell by 12% last year.” One describes an ambition. The other describes a result.

A credible target should explain the boundary, the baseline, the date, and the action plan. It should also be reviewed when assumptions change. A target without a credible plan can become a promise that creates more confidence than the business has earned.

Use words that match the status of the work:

  • Measured: a result supported by a defined method and evidence.
  • Target: a future objective with a date and a stated scope.
  • In progress: work underway, without implying that the outcome has already happened.
  • Certified: a property verified by a named, independent scheme within its stated scope.

Clear status labels help both the audience and the internal team. They prevent a goal in a strategy document from quietly becoming a completed achievement in a campaign.

Keep labels and certifications specific

Badges create trust quickly, which is why they also create risk. A logo can imply that the entire product, company, or supply chain has been independently assessed even when the certification covers one material or one facility.

Always identify the scheme and the scope. “FSC Mix certified paper” is more useful than “certified sustainable packaging.” A certificate number or link may help the customer verify the claim, but it does not expand the certificate beyond what it covers.

The EU rules linked above specifically address sustainability labels and environmental labels that are not based on a certification scheme or established by public authorities. The right treatment depends on the market and the date, so keep the official EU text in your review folder and check national implementation.

Use a simple review workflow

You do not need a large committee for every sentence. You do need the right people at the right points. A practical workflow has four passes.

First, the product or operations owner supplies the fact and the evidence. Second, the marketer writes a short version that stays inside the defined scope. Third, a reviewer who was not involved in the campaign reads it as a customer and records the likely impression. Fourth, legal or regulatory expertise reviews high-risk claims, especially whole-product claims, climate neutrality language, offsets, future targets, and claims that depend on a specific jurisdiction.

The reviewer should be allowed to narrow the claim without being treated as blocking the campaign. A smaller claim that survives scrutiny is more valuable than a larger claim that must be withdrawn after launch.

Our claim checklist follows this workflow: scope, meaning, evidence, method, time, balance, accessible proof, and approval. Use it as a pre-publish gate, then save the completed record with the claim file.

A final editing pass

Before publication, remove any word that is doing more work than the evidence supports. “Leading,” “best,” “responsible,” “sustainable,” “clean,” and “planet friendly” are not automatically forbidden, but each one adds meaning that a customer may reasonably interpret broadly.

Try replacing the adjective with a noun, number, boundary, date, or method. Replace “better packaging” with the actual packaging change. Replace “carbon neutral” with a specific emissions reduction result if that is what you can prove. Replace “sustainable collection” with the material and sourcing fact that supports the narrower message.

The Clear ESG examples page shows this rewrite pattern in action. The point is not to make every message dull. Specific claims can be more persuasive because customers can understand what they are being asked to believe.

Environmental claims are strongest when the wording, evidence, scope, and customer impression line up. That is the whole job. Start with a fact, define its boundary, show the proof, surface the limitation, and check the current rule for the market where the claim will appear.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules and official guidance change. Check the current source for your market and ask a qualified adviser to review high-risk claims before publication.

Keep reading

More practical guidance

GuideGreenwashing Compliance: A Practical ProcessRead the guide

Common questions

Clear answers before you act.

Use these answers to choose your next step. For a live campaign or legal decision, confirm the current rules for your market.

What is the main takeaway from “How to write environmental claims that hold up”?+
A practical guide to writing environmental and ESG claims that are specific, understandable, and supported by evidence.
Can I use this guide as legal advice?+
No. This guide is practical educational information, not legal or regulatory advice. Confirm the current official guidance for your market and ask a qualified adviser to review high-risk claims.
What should I do after reading this guide?+
Apply the ideas to the exact wording you plan to publish. Define the claim's scope, check the evidence and limitations, and use the Clear ESG checklist before release.
Clear ESG logoClear ESG

Plain-English guidance for businesses making environmental claims.

Product

  • The rules
  • Examples
  • Checklist
  • Guides
  • Sources
  • ESG basics
  • Free guide
  • Contact

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Support
© 2026 Clear ESG. All rights reserved.